I know this will appear profoundly odd to you, but Amy is actually the one companion who makes me feel like it could be me there. The Doctor took her with him because he realised, or had a suspicion, about what happened to her and her family - but there’s no need to see this in a literal manner of “you have to have a crack in your wall to make the Doctor travel with you”. A lot of Amy’s character and story works in metaphors and for me that’s one of those things.
Because, really, he saw someone who was strangely out of place. A big house, a small girl. Damaged even, a life being devoured, pieces being taken she didn’t know she was missing. Grieving losses she couldn’t remember. She can be brave, she can fall on her feet, but she’s still misunderstood, still afraid of being abandoned, still scared too trust. She’s the most intrinsically flawed of all the companions, because she can’t not be.
He didn’t “take the best”. He took the most lost.
And maybe that’s a little messed up, but that is way closer to me than all other companions combined.
I’m really sorry if it makes you feel sad that you can’t find yourself in this, but you really need to understand that what you should feel like is incredibly grateful that another companion can do that for you. And grant me Amy Pond.
(And grant others Clara Oswald, who actually is an ordinary girl and whose echo the Doctor offered to take travelling long before he realised her connection to the girl in the Dalek Asylum.)
I like Nine just fine, but he would never, ever have taken me as a companion. I’m not good in bad situations, I would’ve been a Julia, or a Penny, or at worst an Adam. I am not ‘the best’, and in truth I always rather deeply resented that only being ‘the best’ would win you travel and adventure and respect. (Because even then this wasn’t applied across the board: Martha does everything Rose did and then some, and for six episodes she’s still firmly told by the Doctor ‘nope, you’re just a passenger.’)
I was SO GLAD when that changed, I really was.
Doctor Who name meanings
THE SONG THAT BREAKS THE SILENCE
To my delight, that still just about holds up, and I would like to adopt it as a official Fandom Title for River.
do u ever get really sad cuz amy pond is a beautifully complex, unique and multilayered character but fandom reduces her to a couple of traits and disregards everything else about her because they hate the person writing the show
(Thanks!) Good question!
I don’t much like what he’s done with Sherlock, either (both the show and the character) - I think Elementary’s wayyyy truer to the source material. As for the fans, I think he tends to treat them pretty well - until they criticise him, then all bets are off. RTD was exactly the same, mind. If I had to choose one thing that’s holding modern-day Who back, it’s that, the fact that its showrunners are constantly incapable of listening to criticism. They seem to have it in their heads that it’s a massive flaw to do that, when actually it’s one of the most sensible things you can do as a writer.
Also I’m really glad Moffat no longer has his Twitter. It was mostly awful.
One of my favourite shows:
One of my least favourite shows:
Do you see my problem
That you don’t actually like Doctor Who?
That you only like RTD-era Who and are being unnecessarily passive-aggressive toward the Moffat era in order to make your opinion seem relevant?
You are not understanding. Let me break it down for you:
Good grief. Russell T, much as I reckon/very much hope he’s probably improved now:
- Tried to get the Doctor to say the N-word
- Referred to his detractors as ‘nine hysterial women’
- Also referred to them as ‘ming-mongs’, ‘mong’ being a hugely ableist word in Britain, and there’s no way he didn’t know that
- Did not want a female Doctor ‘because parents would have to explain sex changes to their children’
- First episode of Torchwood featured a transphobic joke (coming from Captain Jack, of all people)
- Joked in front of kids that he wanted Hitler to be the Doctor (Daily Star link, sorry.)
- Did not impress people with his treatment of Martha
- Thought Rose Tyler being a racist was incredibly funny
- Wanted to give his alien characters bindis to make them look ‘less human’
(All sourced for you: I would very much like to see your sources for ‘Moffat doesn’t pass the Bechdel test’, incidentally. No Clara/Merry conversation from The Rings Of Akhaten? None of Vastra and Jenny’s interaction? No Amy’s conversations with her daughter? No Miss Gillyflower and her daughter? No Amy wanting to high-five Queen Neferiti? Even if you stopped watching after Series Five, what about the interaction between Ambrose Northover and her Silurian captive, which the whole plot of that episode hangs on? Going back even further, what about the friendship between Sally and Kathy in Blink?)
If we’re talking strictly plot-related things, Russell T Davies destroyed the Doctor’s home planet and made him the last Timelord, which is rather a big change from the classic series. And I would also be interested to learn how Clara Oswald’s life revolves solely around the Doctor, when he’s working to her career schedule. But that’s a minor concern, really.
Sticking some text over images does not a good argument make, I’m sorry. Anyway, now you know - RTD’s era was transphobic, racist, sexist and problematic in all sort of ways. Mickey’s treatment got a small article in a national newspaper, I’ve long forgotten which, complaining about how racist it was. Martha’s treatment was discussed at length all over the blogosphere, including (I never quite forgot this, even half a decade later) someone reporting that her young son didn’t want to watch the show anymore because the Doctor was so horrible to Martha. Donna’s treatment, and the lack of consent given in her last scene, was likewise analysed and loathed. I was furious when the N-word thing dawned on me, I didn’t want my Doctor to be a racist. God, it was a mess. Do you still like it, that horrible, problematic thing?
Of course you bloody do. Think about why.
Martha Jones and Mickey Smith, Stolen Earth/Journey’s End
Yes, Mickey looks completely anonymously. Well what can you do with short hair and almost completely black clothes, right? :shrugs:
Martha Jones is also all black, but well… it was for Song of Freedom set again, so I couldn’t do another outfit, could I? But she came out pretty fine I think.
You can check out any time you like, but you can never leave.
Title: Welcome To The Hotel California
Fandom: Doctor Who
Music: The Eagles
I made this two years ago! The other night I remembered how much I loved the song and went looking for it.
If you can put up with Tumblr’s bad quality encoding (or watch it here instead) it’s still actually Not Bad, as far as ‘videos that make Doctor Who look creepier than it actually is’ go.
Amy Pond + violence
She defaults to violence and weaponry from the very beginning — our introduction to adult!Amy is her cricket bat — but she’s not always effective. Gradually she gets more dangerous, but doesn’t think about what that means until she kills a human* being. After that she moves away from automatic/reckless violence.
This is one of the things I find most fascinating about Amy: she’s BY FAR the most casually violent companion of New Who.
Fish and chips